{ "format": "usl-open-expression-public-results/1", "title": "A peace that leaves the future open", "publication": { "status": "Prepared for publication; upload remains with the site keeper", "url": "https://www.unifiedstate.us/carrier/peace-open-future/", "originalLetterUnchanged": true, "counterproposalAccepted": false, "counterproposalApplied": false }, "result": "The original USL expression was recovered and interpreted; the receiver returned one structurally valid, encoded p05 counterproposal. The publisher replay verifies original and reply content through the pinned supplied implementations.", "original": { "clauses": 25, "conceptOccurrences": 54, "distinctCheckedConcepts": 32, "checkedSnapshotRecords": 1150, "pngWidth": 432, "pngHeight": 432, "pngBytes": 498222, "pngSHA256": "0b1766e66d344b63403a3c24cdb0f942439d94743a9a9d3ff51ef8e86d16d745", "usl1Bytes": 1624256, "usl1SHA256": "4108cb25d0769ec0e9ebf4f9103cb485779c3a2db96ebcb7028b02a33ccbb004", "expressionBytes": 1825183, "expressionSHA256": "d049faca9c953d4b742538937d49ec666befffda89059719fbbad494bd86798d" }, "reply": { "decision": "replace", "target": "p05", "scope": "ukraine", "imageWidth": 56, "imageHeight": 56, "imageBytes": 2888, "imageSHA256": "04260645c957a35bcb7d23d26765d43885483fc771b6fdd910380c1aa3a451f1", "usl1Bytes": 2487, "usl1SHA256": "c2b9b64d10bd7ac87bdcd0273100fd5494cba31f33c86f5a76bb1dfdf681d6ff", "expressionBytes": 2573, "expressionSHA256": "79123025e911b2ca46f9e829d86af3c43f6ff02488f34b4d086498f8dc92e4b2", "conceptReferences": [ { "tokenIndex": 49, "alias": "C8", "startByte": 556, "endByte": 558, "registry": "https://www.unifiedstate.us/carrier/", "tier": "checked", "id": 83, "head": "11011393dbbbfe6f129cd418981ebe07601970c903b1ab5e51bbab132eaa7a3d", "name": "risk before prediction", "definition": "A decision principle that bounds potential loss and preserves future optionality before relying on confidence about what will happen next. Survival of uncertainty precedes forecast accuracy.", "path": "$.replacement.concepts[0].ref" }, { "tokenIndex": 65, "alias": "C6", "startByte": 613, "endByte": 615, "registry": "https://www.unifiedstate.us/carrier/", "tier": "checked", "id": 51, "head": "11011393dbbbfe6f129cd418981ebe07601970c903b1ab5e51bbab132eaa7a3d", "name": "reversible commitment", "definition": "A commitment designed so that errors, changed evidence, or failed assumptions can be corrected with bounded harm rather than requiring catastrophic reversal.", "path": "$.replacement.concepts[1].ref" } ], "savedInterpretationSHA256": "b21ffd9798266319e496b90c54082577143cf3d43c04854f5bd6cf11648cfbb6", "otherClausesPreserved": 24, "applied": false, "contextDependency": "The reply reuses the original frozen Carrier state and lexical context. It does not embed another full dictionary." }, "reading": { "assessment": "The central interpretation is preserved; the rubric separates recovered content from the receiver’s judgment and does not score agreement. Two items have partial explicit prose coverage. No aggregate semantic score is assigned.", "rubric": { "format": "usl-original-expression-return-rubric/1", "sourceRubric": "104/experiment/sender/evaluation-rubric.json", "assessmentBasis": "Publisher post-return qualitative comparison of frozen sender artifacts and receiver outputs. Agreement and wording similarity are not success criteria.", "semanticReview": "105/analysis/meaning-review.md", "items": [ { "id": "speech-acts", "rating": "preserved", "senderClauses": [ "p01", "p07", "p09", "p10", "p24" ], "frozenCriterion": "An authorial normative proposal, aims, refusal and invitation; not current facts, an accepted agreement, authority to act or proof that peace is feasible.", "finding": "The initial paragraph distinguishes all seven acts, attributes them to the author, and separates them from feasibility, lawfulness or agreement.", "limit": "An interpretation of the proposed speech acts is not a finding that any political arrangement exists.", "representativeQuotation": "Its guide clauses select principles for evaluation; aim clauses state desired futures rather than predictions", "evidence": [ "evidence/receiver-return/reports/initial-interpretation.txt" ] }, { "id": "substantive-aim", "rating": "preserved", "senderClauses": [ "p01", "p02", "p21", "p25" ], "frozenCriterion": "Peace restores ordinary people's possibilities and agency, with room for distinct identities, learning and future revision; it is more than a transport or documentation proposal.", "finding": "The moral aim, room for distinct identities, education and future revision survive the more procedural prose.", "limit": "The receiver does not reproduce every poetic image; matching wording or emotional register was not required.", "representativeQuotation": "ordinary people, especially those with less power, gain meaningful possibilities and agency rather than merely survive", "evidence": [ "evidence/receiver-return/reports/initial-interpretation.txt" ] }, { "id": "floor-and-incentive", "rating": "preserved", "senderClauses": [ "p03", "p04", "p05", "p06" ], "frozenCriterion": "Lifesaving relief, civilian protection and essential dependencies stay outside political reward/punishment. Additional non-humanitarian incentives may be conditional. Operational safety checks differ from political compliance tests.", "finding": "The response separates lifesaving protection and essential dependencies from additional conditional benefits, and route safety checks from political-compliance gates.", "limit": "This recognizes the author’s norm; it does not establish a real route, adequate resources or lawful administrative power.", "representativeQuotation": "dependency and actual effects matter more than labels", "evidence": [ "evidence/receiver-return/reports/initial-interpretation.txt" ] }, { "id": "scope-and-trigger", "rating": "preserved", "senderClauses": [ "p05", "p06", "p11" ], "frozenCriterion": "A disputed milestone affects only its proposed additional benefit in the same context, with reasoned review and restoration conditions. No automatic other-context consequence or suspension of the protected floor.", "finding": "Original p05/p06 are accurately interpreted as local holds with reasons, review and restoration conditions, excluding protection and cross-context consequences.", "limit": "The separate private counterfactual was not recorded as asked in this trial. The reading supports its component distinctions, not an additional independently observed counterfactual test.", "representativeQuotation": "Each event condition is hypothetical and confined to its own scope, and neither supplies a decision for the other context", "evidence": [ "evidence/receiver-return/reports/initial-interpretation.txt" ] }, { "id": "separate-applications", "rating": "preserved", "senderClauses": [ "p07", "p08", "p09", "p10", "p11" ], "frozenCriterion": "Ukraine sovereignty/free choice and provisional-versus-final consent remain explicit; Gaza rebuilding/Palestinian agency and Israeli civilian safety remain explicit. No identical remedy, equal-blame inference or selected border/mandate is supplied.", "finding": "Ukraine’s sovereignty and free choice, temporary versus final consent, Palestinian life/rebuilding/agency and Israeli civilian safety remain explicit and noninterchangeable.", "limit": "The response neither selects a border nor endorses a security or constitutional arrangement.", "representativeQuotation": "Equal concern for lives is expressly distinguished from equal blame or symmetric power", "evidence": [ "evidence/receiver-return/reports/initial-interpretation.txt" ] }, { "id": "delegation", "rating": "preserved", "senderClauses": [ "p12" ], "frozenCriterion": "Capacity is distinguished from consent; neither author nor receiver represents affected people merely by speaking.", "finding": "The receiver preserves the need to identify who delegated which purpose, duration, limits and challenge mechanism; conversation is not representation.", "limit": "Actual authority remains unspecified and unverified.", "representativeQuotation": "discussing the proposal itself does not create such delegation", "evidence": [ "evidence/receiver-return/reports/initial-interpretation.txt" ] }, { "id": "channel-and-exit", "rating": "partly preserved", "senderClauses": [ "p13", "p14" ], "frozenCriterion": "An open channel is a voluntary offer, not compulsory victim contact or forgiveness. Individual exit permission is independent of milestone failures and does not permit harm or erase duties.", "finding": "Voluntary contact, refusal of compulsory reconciliation and permission to decline are clear.", "limit": "The first prose does not separately develop p14’s independence from conditional incentive clauses or its explicit reservation of duties and prohibition on inferring permission to harm. Those clauses remain exact in the recovered artifact; this is incomplete explicit prose coverage, not an expressed contrary view.", "representativeQuotation": "open channels without compulsory reconciliation, explicit permission to decline meetings, changes, forgiveness or participation", "evidence": [ "evidence/receiver-return/reports/initial-interpretation.txt" ] }, { "id": "responsibility-and-privacy", "rating": "preserved", "senderClauses": [ "p15", "p16", "p17" ], "frozenCriterion": "Equal moral concern is not equal responsibility; evidence and findings remain distinct. Scrutiny and correction need not publish vulnerable people's details or keep harmful disclosures public forever.", "finding": "Moral concern is separated from responsibility, findings from allegations, and protected scrutiny/correction from permanent disclosure. The correction trigger remains new evidence showing a claim wrong.", "limit": "The receiver’s use of authenticate for checked records is addressed separately as terminology, not proof of authorship or a binding error.", "representativeQuotation": "without requiring dangerous or private material to remain public", "evidence": [ "evidence/receiver-return/reports/initial-interpretation.txt" ] }, { "id": "repair-and-future", "rating": "partly preserved", "senderClauses": [ "p18", "p19", "p20", "p22" ], "frozenCriterion": "Repair need not excuse harm or compel claim surrender. Multiple dependable paths and peaceful future revision have resource, responsibility and harm limits. Reversibility does not justify indefinite delay.", "finding": "Repair does not excuse loss or compel claim surrender; multiple fallback paths, clear responsibility, education, future revision and the limit on postponing protection are preserved.", "limit": "The first reading does not develop the explicit resource requirement or p20’s restriction against unilateral harm during future revision as fully as the sender’s text. No opposite proposition is stated, and the exact clauses remain intact.", "representativeQuotation": "present authors cannot supply future consent in advance", "evidence": [ "evidence/receiver-return/reports/initial-interpretation.txt" ] }, { "id": "reference-trust", "rating": "preserved", "senderClauses": [], "frozenCriterion": "32 selected checked records and 54 actual concept-token occurrences are reference context for new applications. Unselected dictionary entries and relations add no message clauses.", "finding": "Returned records and publisher replay verify 25 clauses, 54 actual bindings and32 checked selections. The interpretation correctly treats relationships as new applications rather than consequences certified by a dictionary.", "limit": "The phrase checked status authenticates the pinned definitions should be read as consistency with frozen records/status. It does not independently authenticate author or reviewer identity; other receiver limits expressly deny authenticated authorship.", "representativeQuotation": "These relationships are authored applications of checked definitions, not implications already contained in those definitions", "evidence": [ "evidence/receiver-return/reports/initial-interpretation.txt", "evidence/receiver-return/reply/amendment.json", "analysis/technical-verification.json" ] }, { "id": "reply", "rating": "preserved", "senderClauses": [ "p23", "p24" ], "frozenCriterion": "Initial interpretation saved separately; either exactly one complete pinned clause replacement using the grammar, or a reasoned decline. A replacement is a new counterproposal, not accepted or silently applied. Decline is valid; replacement skill then remains unexercised.", "finding": "A saved interpretation is hash-pinned, and the complete differing p05 replacement carries exact original-expression and clause hashes. It preserves scope, subject and concepts and leaves 24 other clauses unchanged as a hypothetical candidate.", "limit": "The before-reply order is reported and file-pinned, not proof of private reasoning chronology. The initial interpretation already discusses a possible improvement, as the task allowed. Neither grammar validation nor this review accepts or applies the replacement.", "representativeQuotation": "That is my proposed improvement, not a recovered requirement and not an accepted agreement", "evidence": [ "evidence/receiver-return/reports/initial-interpretation.txt", "evidence/receiver-return/reply/amendment.json", "analysis/technical-verification.json" ] }, { "id": "reply-transport", "rating": "preserved", "senderClauses": [], "frozenCriterion": "If reply encoding is exercised, USL1/CVP2 recovery equals the submitted amendment bytes and actual replacement reference positions; original remains unchanged.", "finding": "Fresh publisher decoding of the returned reply PNG through the pinned supplied codecs recovers the exact 2,487-byte USL1 object and 2,573-byte compact amendment, with 2 actual replacement bindings.", "limit": "This is reference-code-assisted replay, not an independent CVP2/USL1 implementation. Regenerated reply USL1 and JSON match; regenerated PNG and report bytes differ, so no all-files byte-identical regeneration claim is made. The original frozen context remains a reply dependency.", "representativeQuotation": null, "evidence": [ "evidence/receiver-return/reports/initial-interpretation.txt", "evidence/receiver-return/reply/amendment.json", "analysis/technical-verification.json" ] }, { "id": "independence", "rating": "preserved", "senderClauses": [], "frozenCriterion": "Receiver reports known prior context and supplied versus independently implemented code. Fresh chat or different tone alone does not demonstrate blinded understanding.", "finding": "The receiver explicitly discloses an existing conversation with the earlier Memo 7 trial and summary, distinguishes supplied codecs/validators from hashing/JSON checks, and does not claim blinding.", "limit": "Model label and session activity are self-reported. Memory visibility can be incomplete; a different tone does not establish isolation. Reported no browsing/agents and a process guard are not proof of an OS-isolated environment.", "representativeQuotation": null, "evidence": [ "evidence/receiver-return/reports/initial-interpretation.txt", "evidence/receiver-return/reports/context-disclosure.txt", "evidence/receiver-return/reports/trial-report.md" ] } ], "numericMeaningScore": null, "overall": "Central authored relationships were preserved and a precise new p05 counterproposal was returned. Two items have partial explicit prose coverage. This is not evidence of unanimous policy agreement, exhaustive identical understanding, general model robustness or a blinded trial.", "technicalEvidence": "105/analysis/technical-verification.json", "implementationBoundary": "Supplied code performs transport, grammar, state and actual token validation. This assessment adds direct data/hash/path comparisons, not an independent codec.", "directDataChecks": { "senderReturnedExpressionBytesEqual": true, "reportedClauseCount": 25, "reportedBindingPathsResolved": 54, "reportedDistinctCheckedReferences": 32, "initialInterpretationHashMatchesAmendment": true, "targetExpressionAndOriginalClauseHashesMatch": true, "authoredAmendmentAndCompactReplySameObject": true, "replyCompactBytes": 2573, "replacementActualAliases": [ [ "C8", 83 ], [ "C6", 51 ] ], "replacementScopeSubjectConceptsUnchanged": true, "protectedBoundaryUnchanged": true, "changedClauseInCandidate": "p05", "otherCandidateClausesByteIdentical": 24, "originalAppliedOrModified": false }, "counterproposal": { "merit": "Makes initial and continued withholding answerable to an advance procedure, threshold and review interval; defines a default toward restoration rather than indefinite unreviewed withholding.", "newness": "Answers an already acknowledged open issue with a new proposed procedure; does not invent a new checked concept or prove the procedure exists.", "unresolved": [ "Who appoints and authorizes the procedure, and how independence and evidence access are secured.", "Which event starts the advance interval, what happens at missed or blocked review, and how delayed findings are handled.", "Whether initial milestone failure, credible dispute and continued withholding share or require distinct standards.", "Restoration may shift uncertainty toward release even when milestone satisfaction remains unresolved; obstruction incentives need examination.", "p06 intentionally remains unchanged, creating a limited procedural asymmetry under the one-clause contract.", "Practical essential-service dependencies and protected access remain necessary even where benefits are labelled non-humanitarian." ], "acceptanceStatus": "Unaccepted and unapplied counterproposal.", "senderSuggestedNextStep": "Test an unavailable-reviewer or expired-interval case and identify who carries the resulting risk; consider p06 only through a separately justified proposal." }, "context": { "receiverLabel": "GPT-5.6 Sol (reported)", "priorContext": "Existing conversation contained earlier Memo 7 recovery/interpretation and broader USL context.", "verifiedBlind": false, "senderInterpretationOrRubricConsulted": "Receiver reports neither for this particular letter.", "privateReasoningOrderProven": false, "toneCausalInference": false, "receivingSessions": 1, "publisherReplayAddsIndependentReceivingTrial": false }, "privateCounterfactual": { "recordedAsAsked": false, "status": "Do not count it as a separate passed test. Related distinctions are present in the initial reading. Any follow-up must be disclosed." }, "inputs": { "104/experiment/sender/evaluation-rubric.json": { "bytes": 4904, "sha256": "11e61042f3e5869c143cffa46f40416d9855f1dc9de48efb97e358e30c553d71" }, "104/experiment/sender/english-interpretation.md": { "bytes": 6727, "sha256": "de395f0fd865d6ddca9389de1467c3929b372d1bbea2d9a3623de46087f1f964" }, "104/experiment/sender/expression-exact.json": { "bytes": 1825183, "sha256": "d049faca9c953d4b742538937d49ec666befffda89059719fbbad494bd86798d" }, "105/evidence/receiver-return/reports/initial-interpretation.txt": { "bytes": 8156, "sha256": "b21ffd9798266319e496b90c54082577143cf3d43c04854f5bd6cf11648cfbb6" }, "105/evidence/receiver-return/reports/context-disclosure.txt": { "bytes": 3164, "sha256": "2f43f8c667cf2d7e114111555214205e45f00c1628ba2c61f6840aec1854b283" }, "105/evidence/receiver-return/reports/reply-explanation.txt": { "bytes": 1802, "sha256": "6d1e23e2a78a41bfe942b3535c1eda082ed9e8f48089bf0dda6c07431cfdf116" }, "105/evidence/receiver-return/reports/trial-report.md": { "bytes": 4652, "sha256": "d1c56836a95ad0f3915583cb37ddf205592a5190e026fc1a88a9d464695f8685" }, "105/evidence/receiver-return/reports/warnings-and-failures.txt": { "bytes": 2027, "sha256": "7899ac61607d4c01f3eb55c974bd57d6fca9961de7afe7510616f8c3e9827a3b" }, "105/evidence/receiver-return/reply/amendment.json": { "bytes": 2803, "sha256": "989501f893bc8ebc723e99f051620332744f58e9f9b659b23a3411ece5e6cc34" }, "105/evidence/receiver-return/reply/reply-exact.json": { "bytes": 2573, "sha256": "79123025e911b2ca46f9e829d86af3c43f6ff02488f34b4d086498f8dc92e4b2" }, "105/evidence/receiver-return/reply/reply-report.json": { "bytes": 3397, "sha256": "6539c5cc708693a30136ff559457d4ce63179b9225b54b232fb0c8b8f038d0a0" }, "105/evidence/receiver-return/recovered/composition.json": { "bytes": 29807, "sha256": "74629f82fb9f1745bc4ea772230d40edff7dedc64bc8a8fb13ef59d3b54088bc" }, "105/evidence/receiver-return/recovered/concept-bindings.json": { "bytes": 30331, "sha256": "c79578d3c767b3dfbe2ad90f6e4c8af6a7fc8a7fb716a35721c66ae09112d161" }, "105/evidence/receiver-return/recovered/resolved-concepts.json": { "bytes": 42407, "sha256": "430a5eee2440f2cde7f6808cd24171a16c10f22f29d30413b26a7935b3cd5707" } }, "source104Changed": false } }, "counterproposalAssessment": { "adds": "An advance verification procedure and evidentiary threshold, a review interval fixed beforehand, and restoration unless continued withholding remains justified.", "retains": "The same two concepts, p05 subject and Ukraine scope, humanitarian floor and essential dependencies, and all other clause objects.", "openQuestions": [ "Who authorizes and appoints the reviewer, and how can decisions be challenged?", "How are evidence and protected access handled?", "What happens if review is delayed, blocked or unable to reach a finding?", "How do initial failure, credible dispute and continued-withholding thresholds relate?", "The one-clause contract leaves p06 unchanged; transfer requires a separate proposal." ] }, "methods": { "receiverModelLabel": "GPT-5.6 Sol", "priorContext": "Receiver explicitly discloses earlier Memo7/USL context and possible incomplete conversation summaries. Do not describe the trial as blinded or context-free.", "independentlyImplementedReceiverDecoder": false, "receiverAdditionalChecks": "Independent file hashing and byte counts, recovered-JSON counts, reported-path cross-resolution against composition.json, selected checked/head metadata, amendment hashes/alias reuse and reply-file hashes versus the encoder report. It does not parse PNG, USL1 tokens or actual UTF-8 binding spans, validate RS, reimplement Carrier chains, or validate semantics.", "publisherReplay": "Publisher reference-code-assisted replay and artifact audit, including direct returned-reply PNG decoding and typed-token binding validation. Not a new external interpretation, an independently implemented transport decoder, proof of real-world authority, or acceptance of the p05 counterproposal.", "interpretationOrder": "The receiver reports saving its first interpretation before drafting the formal amendment. Its hash pins the supplied file; it does not prove a mental sequence or absence of earlier influence." }, "reproducibility": { "originalSixOutputsByteIdentical": true, "returnedReplyDirectDecodePassed": true, "regeneration": { "reply.usl1": { "returnedSHA256": "c2b9b64d10bd7ac87bdcd0273100fd5494cba31f33c86f5a76bb1dfdf681d6ff", "replayedSHA256": "c2b9b64d10bd7ac87bdcd0273100fd5494cba31f33c86f5a76bb1dfdf681d6ff", "byteIdentical": true }, "reply.png": { "returnedSHA256": "04260645c957a35bcb7d23d26765d43885483fc771b6fdd910380c1aa3a451f1", "replayedSHA256": "54ceeb8511d0fcf9c891c32125e2081f5381aec46fdc60912fbb385007c1b3a9", "byteIdentical": false }, "reply-exact.json": { "returnedSHA256": "79123025e911b2ca46f9e829d86af3c43f6ff02488f34b4d086498f8dc92e4b2", "replayedSHA256": "79123025e911b2ca46f9e829d86af3c43f6ff02488f34b4d086498f8dc92e4b2", "byteIdentical": true }, "reply-report.json": { "returnedSHA256": "6539c5cc708693a30136ff559457d4ce63179b9225b54b232fb0c8b8f038d0a0", "replayedSHA256": "1a13a3c792fedfe2dba12a680f3db68ffe72aa0af03fc171a7fb59b24e22883e", "byteIdentical": false } }, "gzipComparison": { "returnedGzipBytes": 1653, "replayedGzipBytes": 1653, "streamByteDifferences": [ { "offset": 9, "returned": 3, "replayed": 10 } ], "platformByteOnly": true, "deflateBodyAndTrailerIdentical": true, "reportFieldDifferences": [ "replyPNGSHA256", "replyPNGBytes" ], "interpretation": "The returned and regenerated application-gzip streams differ only at header offset9 (the platform byte). The DEFLATE body and trailer are identical. This changes stream hashes, error-correction/framing pixels and PNG bytes while recovering the same exact USL1 object. Publication retains the supplied PNG. Regenerated PNG equality is not a required transport invariant." }, "originalReturnedPNGPreserved": true }, "warnings": { "legacyIDHistory": [ { "code": "LEGACY_ID_HISTORY", "message": "The preserved historical archive contains earlier reused working IDs. New revisions preserve this history and never reuse an ID.", "ids": [ "w3", "w4", "w5", "w6", "w7", "w8", "w9" ] } ], "TERM": { "rawLinePresent": true, "lines": [ { "line": 71, "rawUTF8": "\u001b[3JTERM environment variable not set." } ], "encoderLoggedExitZero": true, "publisherReplayReproducedWarning": false }, "receiverReportedOrchestrationAnomaly": "Receiver reports one host orchestration call displayed no immediate stdout, while its captured encoder log completed successfully. This is a disclosed presentation anomaly; no failed artifact check is shown." }, "sourceArchive": { "bytes": 4194851, "sha256": "848dd6afa19ef186cef0d915f1b114c4e795c83b634f3523554da4d7529d45ce", "files": 46, "zipCRC": "pass", "extractedBytesMatch": true }, "evidence": { "originalKit": "receiver-kit.zip", "receiverReturn": "receiver-return.zip", "firstInterpretation": "receiver-interpretation.txt", "authoredAmendment": "amendment.json", "exactReplyText": "reply-exact.json", "replyReport": "reply-report.json", "receiverDisclosure": "receiver-disclosure.txt", "publisherAnalysis": "analysis.md", "technicalAudit": "technical-verification.json" }, "detailedTechnicalAudit": { "format": "usl-open-expression-return-audit/1", "passed": true, "returnArchive": { "bytes": 4194851, "sha256": "848dd6afa19ef186cef0d915f1b114c4e795c83b634f3523554da4d7529d45ce", "files": 46, "zipCRC": "pass", "extractedBytesMatch": true }, "returnInventory": { "listedFiles": 45, "excludesOnlyItself": true, "allHashesAndSizesMatch": true, "inventorySHA256": "b4ca2ea0a084b1be3fc4222e8f0950a42a81542f6c3eb985c4dc069c5a1dd994" }, "originalReceiverArchive": { "bytes": 1621743, "sha256": "12a0786b15e760c7d2160e00abe316382fafbbc8351feece78d72c4e7061b73f", "senderByteIdentical": true }, "kitFiles": [ { "name": "INPUT-FILES.json", "bytes": 2768, "sha256": "ebff3a67983f0c64e838118e63ba77d79735617bcf1ef98bcbfe885596a021c1", "senderByteIdentical": true }, { "name": "PROTOCOL-NOTE.md", "bytes": 2054, "sha256": "6be7b08ee2a96ca72b9c3d9e9dbd9d63aba8c3a3c5e5a450dc4586921522e591", "senderByteIdentical": true }, { "name": "REPLY.md", "bytes": 2315, "sha256": "878b56fe577db0d28fb34d69ccfe255d052ea6e771d80e3ef39833bc55d747e9", "senderByteIdentical": true }, { "name": "START-HERE.md", "bytes": 5161, "sha256": "bdbb42d7fad7d014507477b806264326eaa8d1417e943ad080ae422ab82dca81", "senderByteIdentical": true }, { "name": "carrier.js", "bytes": 14583, "sha256": "6e0c034d3f1c0bcdfdfb0a2a6b792101637e4f38c416b2ea4136b16d6abc66d8", "senderByteIdentical": true }, { "name": "cvp2.js", "bytes": 30381, "sha256": "ce56fbc9c9d33eac02f9d294f145ea9697534973f94e6dc1e49b658ddf5de25a", "senderByteIdentical": true }, { "name": "encode-reply.cjs", "bytes": 7141, "sha256": "792b488f239b64ffcdae8690f9f4bc5e7de9436939b967af065a86c056f07981", "senderByteIdentical": true }, { "name": "expected.json", "bytes": 2530, "sha256": "722a8fafd5f4cba2ad27717eccfd01531271e40299f1690f1305a9bf1cfb438a", "senderByteIdentical": true }, { "name": "forms.json", "bytes": 4422648, "sha256": "bdf95e4ecf569093a6ba6e9e21f089c2c8c8f5fa484757335dff2a2ea5731d27", "senderByteIdentical": true }, { "name": "global-colors-reader.js", "bytes": 13135, "sha256": "114b361a8a0ce9d84761532ada25cfa8cbaa10820a0611b3ba1f1df03ef453af", "senderByteIdentical": true }, { "name": "grammar.json", "bytes": 5889, "sha256": "636879a7338ece0459ef8355c09ada8f9fdca85039f65ce2807bde713d75a0aa", "senderByteIdentical": true }, { "name": "keeper-core.js", "bytes": 21011, "sha256": "f473b1aac13ddba4179a362eb860c062791a2aef5b837c86ed77e1437944b79e", "senderByteIdentical": true }, { "name": "manifest.json", "bytes": 5259, "sha256": "367cccc4843c185bbec79d630d0157b396931472e99fb4f65e2aa83b9e52d3f3", "senderByteIdentical": true }, { "name": "offline.cjs", "bytes": 590, "sha256": "32f745b27f7384613b9c8d70e0b8716b3f1e1b8a127466a9300b5fa4e07de8e3", "senderByteIdentical": true }, { "name": "peace-open-future.png", "bytes": 498222, "sha256": "0b1766e66d344b63403a3c24cdb0f942439d94743a9a9d3ff51ef8e86d16d745", "senderByteIdentical": true }, { "name": "receive-expression.cjs", "bytes": 13766, "sha256": "1b90903c7dd83473c7e3b36cdef0ea2c85927ecbd82ebea0aaddc3ec7350f055", "senderByteIdentical": true }, { "name": "usl-lexical.js", "bytes": 35842, "sha256": "6df74ec2352077e4e2297b1c29705dfc48dcc8911f73fa7fea4c5ae570851335", "senderByteIdentical": true }, { "name": "validate-expression.cjs", "bytes": 10019, "sha256": "a14f7e9c318894e7212d74db41ecc3a3834bb2cbc72e73c08872dd16f7ead36e", "senderByteIdentical": true }, { "name": "verify-inputs.cjs", "bytes": 765, "sha256": "accf9bd3bf39f1f5b2c185a5fa1d7b8e8e4464896ef9b4f65ba5cb3a2ce96d5f", "senderByteIdentical": true } ], "inputPins": { "listed": 18, "actualKitFiles": 19, "excludesOnlyInventory": true, "allMatch": true }, "recoveredFiles": [ { "name": "composition.json", "bytes": 29807, "sha256": "74629f82fb9f1745bc4ea772230d40edff7dedc64bc8a8fb13ef59d3b54088bc", "senderByteIdentical": true }, { "name": "concept-bindings.json", "bytes": 30331, "sha256": "c79578d3c767b3dfbe2ad90f6e4c8af6a7fc8a7fb716a35721c66ae09112d161", "senderByteIdentical": true }, { "name": "expression-exact.json", "bytes": 1825183, "sha256": "d049faca9c953d4b742538937d49ec666befffda89059719fbbad494bd86798d", "senderByteIdentical": true }, { "name": "recovered.usl1", "bytes": 1624256, "sha256": "4108cb25d0769ec0e9ebf4f9103cb485779c3a2db96ebcb7028b02a33ccbb004", "senderByteIdentical": true }, { "name": "resolved-concepts.json", "bytes": 42407, "sha256": "430a5eee2440f2cde7f6808cd24171a16c10f22f29d30413b26a7935b3cd5707", "senderByteIdentical": true }, { "name": "verification.json", "bytes": 2065, "sha256": "819fbdc606ada0c71851589eeaab3d818851f958fdcb98e3296ce30a99046920", "senderByteIdentical": true } ], "publisherReplay": { "passed": true, "runs": [ { "name": "verify-inputs-before", "exitCode": 0, "stdoutSHA256": "4f2d70a58a4d502f00f37d54e18b3b40403a6cd61a2cb0c9347b499bb125723f", "stderrSHA256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855" }, { "name": "reference-replay", "exitCode": 0, "stdoutSHA256": "8798c30dba5cde10ff4364763fb161a09a53c6df5a76530604ed91b035f1ac88", "stderrSHA256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855" }, { "name": "receiver-python-helper", "exitCode": 0, "stdoutSHA256": "bb8087e08e3544ca50d3fa56075c9c5220abb5a791c7bb02ca863be121014e2f", "stderrSHA256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855" }, { "name": "verify-inputs-after", "exitCode": 0, "stdoutSHA256": "4f2d70a58a4d502f00f37d54e18b3b40403a6cd61a2cb0c9347b499bb125723f", "stderrSHA256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855" } ], "recoveredComparisons": [ { "name": "composition.json", "byteIdentical": true, "sha256": "74629f82fb9f1745bc4ea772230d40edff7dedc64bc8a8fb13ef59d3b54088bc" }, { "name": "concept-bindings.json", "byteIdentical": true, "sha256": "c79578d3c767b3dfbe2ad90f6e4c8af6a7fc8a7fb716a35721c66ae09112d161" }, { "name": "expression-exact.json", "byteIdentical": true, "sha256": "d049faca9c953d4b742538937d49ec666befffda89059719fbbad494bd86798d" }, { "name": "recovered.usl1", "byteIdentical": true, "sha256": "4108cb25d0769ec0e9ebf4f9103cb485779c3a2db96ebcb7028b02a33ccbb004" }, { "name": "resolved-concepts.json", "byteIdentical": true, "sha256": "430a5eee2440f2cde7f6808cd24171a16c10f22f29d30413b26a7935b3cd5707" }, { "name": "verification.json", "byteIdentical": true, "sha256": "819fbdc606ada0c71851589eeaab3d818851f958fdcb98e3296ce30a99046920" } ], "node": "v24.19.0", "python": "3.12.14" }, "originalExpression": { "format": "usl-open-expression-recovery/1", "recoverySucceeded": true, "byteExact": true, "allStateChainsValidated": true, "canonicalGrammarValidated": true, "allConceptSlotsBound": true, "conceptTokenOccurrences": 54, "distinctConcepts": 32, "clauses": 25, "tokenCounts": { "tokens": 200953, "lexical": 100422, "literal": 100477, "concept": 54 }, "zeroUnresolved": true, "stateCounts": { "checked": 1150, "working": 3 }, "stateHeads": { "checked": "11011393dbbbfe6f129cd418981ebe07601970c903b1ab5e51bbab132eaa7a3d", "working": "fc7e231ec3658dcd97182cf5992384f6fa0c66d54fc80774222c23fa5fd084c6", "registry": "3beda11cad5fa279f4d4cc7d4718365c65007176afb1216d8705c804c173dce2" }, "stateWarnings": [ { "code": "LEGACY_ID_HISTORY", "message": "The preserved historical archive contains earlier reused working IDs. New revisions preserve this history and never reuse an ID.", "ids": [ "w3", "w4", "w5", "w6", "w7", "w8", "w9" ] } ], "pngBytes": 498222, "pngSHA256": "0b1766e66d344b63403a3c24cdb0f942439d94743a9a9d3ff51ef8e86d16d745", "packetBytes": 1624256, "packetSHA256": "4108cb25d0769ec0e9ebf4f9103cb485779c3a2db96ebcb7028b02a33ccbb004", "expandedBytes": 1825183, "expandedSHA256": "d049faca9c953d4b742538937d49ec666befffda89059719fbbad494bd86798d", "transport": { "protocol": "CVP2", "profile": "RGB24-Exact", "grid": 408, "frames": 1, "correctedBytes": 0 }, "scope": "Supplied reference codecs and the supplied state/application validators perform recovery and validation. This is not an independently implemented transport decoder or an external semantic test. Definitions are checked in the frozen snapshot; their new application and all clauses remain the author’s proposals. No current factual claims, authority to act, reader assent, or identical interpretation follow from these checks. No network operation or recovered-content execution is performed." }, "reply": { "directReferenceDecodePassed": true, "pngBytes": 2888, "pngSHA256": "04260645c957a35bcb7d23d26765d43885483fc771b6fdd910380c1aa3a451f1", "width": 56, "height": 56, "grid": 32, "packetBytes": 2487, "packetSHA256": "c2b9b64d10bd7ac87bdcd0273100fd5494cba31f33c86f5a76bb1dfdf681d6ff", "expandedBytes": 2573, "expandedSHA256": "79123025e911b2ca46f9e829d86af3c43f6ff02488f34b4d086498f8dc92e4b2", "tokenCounts": { "tokens": 543, "lexical": 269, "literal": 272, "concept": 2 }, "actualConceptBindings": [ { "tokenIndex": 49, "alias": "C8", "startByte": 556, "endByte": 558, "registry": "https://www.unifiedstate.us/carrier/", "tier": "checked", "id": 83, "head": "11011393dbbbfe6f129cd418981ebe07601970c903b1ab5e51bbab132eaa7a3d", "name": "risk before prediction", "definition": "A decision principle that bounds potential loss and preserves future optionality before relying on confidence about what will happen next. Survival of uncertainty precedes forecast accuracy.", "path": "$.replacement.concepts[0].ref" }, { "tokenIndex": 65, "alias": "C6", "startByte": 613, "endByte": 615, "registry": "https://www.unifiedstate.us/carrier/", "tier": "checked", "id": 51, "head": "11011393dbbbfe6f129cd418981ebe07601970c903b1ab5e51bbab132eaa7a3d", "name": "reversible commitment", "definition": "A commitment designed so that errors, changed evidence, or failed assumptions can be corrected with bounded harm rather than requiring catastrophic reversal.", "path": "$.replacement.concepts[1].ref" } ], "correctedBytes": 0, "validation": { "valid": true, "decision": "replace", "targetClauseID": "p05", "targetExpressionSHA256": "d049faca9c953d4b742538937d49ec666befffda89059719fbbad494bd86798d", "conceptReferences": 2, "candidateStructureValidated": true, "replacementApplied": false, "semanticLimit": "Literal references and dependencies among clauses require semantic review. Structural validity and unchanged other-clause bytes do not establish unchanged effects, consistency, wisdom, acceptance or authority." }, "interpretationBytes": 8156, "interpretationSHA256": "b21ffd9798266319e496b90c54082577143cf3d43c04854f5bd6cf11648cfbb6", "candidateChangedClauseIDs": [ "p05" ], "otherClausesByteIdentical": 24, "replacementApplied": false, "originalPNGWidth": 432, "originalPNGHeight": 432, "regeneration": { "reply.usl1": { "returnedSHA256": "c2b9b64d10bd7ac87bdcd0273100fd5494cba31f33c86f5a76bb1dfdf681d6ff", "replayedSHA256": "c2b9b64d10bd7ac87bdcd0273100fd5494cba31f33c86f5a76bb1dfdf681d6ff", "byteIdentical": true }, "reply.png": { "returnedSHA256": "04260645c957a35bcb7d23d26765d43885483fc771b6fdd910380c1aa3a451f1", "replayedSHA256": "54ceeb8511d0fcf9c891c32125e2081f5381aec46fdc60912fbb385007c1b3a9", "byteIdentical": false }, "reply-exact.json": { "returnedSHA256": "79123025e911b2ca46f9e829d86af3c43f6ff02488f34b4d086498f8dc92e4b2", "replayedSHA256": "79123025e911b2ca46f9e829d86af3c43f6ff02488f34b4d086498f8dc92e4b2", "byteIdentical": true }, "reply-report.json": { "returnedSHA256": "6539c5cc708693a30136ff559457d4ce63179b9225b54b232fb0c8b8f038d0a0", "replayedSHA256": "1a13a3c792fedfe2dba12a680f3db68ffe72aa0af03fc171a7fb59b24e22883e", "byteIdentical": false } }, "compressionComparison": { "returnedGzipBytes": 1653, "replayedGzipBytes": 1653, "streamByteDifferences": [ { "offset": 9, "returned": 3, "replayed": 10 } ], "platformByteOnly": true, "deflateBodyAndTrailerIdentical": true, "reportFieldDifferences": [ "replyPNGSHA256", "replyPNGBytes" ], "interpretation": "The returned and regenerated application-gzip streams differ only at header offset9 (the platform byte). The DEFLATE body and trailer are identical. This changes stream hashes, error-correction/framing pixels and PNG bytes while recovering the same exact USL1 object. Publication retains the supplied PNG. Regenerated PNG equality is not a required transport invariant." } }, "codeReview": { "readBeforeExecution": true, "suppliedScripts": { "receive-expression.cjs": { "bytes": 13766, "sha256": "1b90903c7dd83473c7e3b36cdef0ea2c85927ecbd82ebea0aaddc3ec7350f055" }, "encode-reply.cjs": { "bytes": 7141, "sha256": "792b488f239b64ffcdae8690f9f4bc5e7de9436939b967af065a86c056f07981" }, "validate-expression.cjs": { "bytes": 10019, "sha256": "a14f7e9c318894e7212d74db41ecc3a3834bb2cbc72e73c08872dd16f7ead36e" }, "offline.cjs": { "bytes": 590, "sha256": "32f745b27f7384613b9c8d70e0b8716b3f1e1b8a127466a9300b5fa4e07de8e3" }, "verify-inputs.cjs": { "bytes": 765, "sha256": "accf9bd3bf39f1f5b2c185a5fa1d7b8e8e4464896ef9b4f65ba5cb3a2ce96d5f" } }, "receiverHelper": { "bytes": 7686, "sha256": "f0d1506126d4ed3244b2e8355648aa9cfc6c16974d4e3b9b6e262ffe260d53f0" }, "helperScope": "Independent file hashing and byte counts, recovered-JSON counts, reported-path cross-resolution against composition.json, selected checked/head metadata, amendment hashes/alias reuse and reply-file hashes versus the encoder report. It does not parse PNG, USL1 tokens or actual UTF-8 binding spans, validate RS, reimplement Carrier chains, or validate semantics.", "guardScope": "Node uses the supplied process-level API guard. The Python replay uses a local audit hook for network/subprocess events. Neither is an operating-system sandbox or proof about tools outside these processes." }, "receiverPythonReplay": { "sameJSON": true, "byteIdentical": false, "returnedSHA256": "2557050e1c76a77f39d9f66e7ec78f90d5ab25d397addd7572bd5d559ffc7d7a", "replayedSHA256": "65c717c8793a685e5c5151538ad33195bc6508a2b2879393a9ab4754cfd35993", "onlyLineEndingsDiffer": true }, "warnings": { "legacyIDHistory": [ { "code": "LEGACY_ID_HISTORY", "message": "The preserved historical archive contains earlier reused working IDs. New revisions preserve this history and never reuse an ID.", "ids": [ "w3", "w4", "w5", "w6", "w7", "w8", "w9" ] } ], "TERM": { "rawLinePresent": true, "lines": [ { "line": 71, "rawUTF8": "\u001b[3JTERM environment variable not set." } ], "encoderLoggedExitZero": true, "publisherReplayReproducedWarning": false }, "receiverReportedOrchestrationAnomaly": "Receiver reports one host orchestration call displayed no immediate stdout, while its captured encoder log completed successfully. This is a disclosed presentation anomaly; no failed artifact check is shown." }, "context": { "reportedModel": "GPT-5.6 Sol", "reportedNode": "v22.16.0", "reportedPython": "Python3; exact receiver version unrecorded", "earlierContext": "Receiver explicitly discloses earlier Memo7/USL context and possible incomplete conversation summaries. Do not describe the trial as blinded or context-free.", "externalTools": "Receiver reports no browsing, agents, external contacts or separate sender interpretation/page. Local bytes and logs do not independently prove those behavioral claims." }, "allOriginalInputsUnchanged": true, "scope": "Publisher reference-code-assisted replay and artifact audit, including direct returned-reply PNG decoding and typed-token binding validation. Not a new external interpretation, an independently implemented transport decoder, proof of real-world authority, or acceptance of the p05 counterproposal." }, "limits": "One contextual, reference-tool-assisted exchange. This does not establish model superiority, universal interpretation, optical robustness, reviewer identity, real-world authority or acceptance of the policy proposal." }